Executive Recruiter - Talent Strategist
Fanatics · New York, NY, United States ·
- Category
- Recruiting
- Experience
- 10+ years
About Us
About the Company
Fanatics Collectibles is a new company operating at the intersection of collectibles, culture, and technology. Backed by world-class investors, operators, and sports & entertainment partners, we are building the global leader in next-generation collectibles. As part of the broader Fanatics ecosystem, we leverage a digital sports platform that spans over 900 sports properties and engages more than 81 million fans. Together, we are reimagining every part of the collectibles experience for fans, partners, and creators.
Role Summary
Fanatics Collectibles is building the future of sports collecting — and the leaders we hire will define what that looks like. Based in New York City, this is a relationship management role where you will own and grow our strategic talent network referral program, build and steward a world-class talent bench, and drive full-cycle recruitment for selected VP+ leadership roles. Success in this role will be driven by the quality of the relationships and talent networks you cultivate.
You are a strategic relationship builder and trusted advisor who takes a consultative approach to identifying the right talent for Fanatics Collectibles. You’ll manage executive referrals, keep an engaged bench of candidates mapped across every key function, and work with stakeholders who will expect you to learn our business and have a point of view on the talent we bring into the organization.
What You'll Own
Referral Management
- Own, evolve, and grow the top-performer referral program — a key driver of our hiring network strategy. This is not a passive intake process: you actively cultivate referral sources, network them through Collectibles, and hold the program to a high standard.
- Manage every executive referral from first touch through disposition — ensure every referral is appropriately tracked and remains engaged throughout the process.
- Build and maintain an active bench — a curated roster of warmed, relationship-managed leaders across every key function. Continuously expand and strengthen the executive talent bench through ongoing relationship development and market mapping.
- Own the health and hygiene of executive referral data in Greenhouse CRM — profiles tagged, stages current, outreach logged.
- Deliver weekly reporting to TA and business leadership on talent coming in from our strategic talent network: screens completed, HM conversations, offers extended, and full pipeline disposition.
VP+ Full-Cycle Recruiting
- Own end-to-end recruitment for some executive roles across all non-tech functions at Fanatics Collectibles — from kick-off through close. Leverage established talent pipelines and relationships to accelerate executive search efforts.
- Partner directly with C-suite and senior leadership to understand role requirements, success profiles, and the cultural bar for leadership hires.
- Maintain a deep, living bench of executive talent by function. Relationships are built and sustained through regular touchpoints.
- Lead and manage executive search firm partnerships — in partnership with finance, - scope engagement terms, set clear expectations, manage deliverables, and hold firms accountable to our hiring bar and timeline. Know when to run a search yourself through your own network and when to bring in a retained partner.
- Leverage LinkedIn Recruiter and LinkedIn Talent Insights to map executive talent markets, identify movement signals, and build targeted slates with conviction.
- Conduct executive-level screens and assessments; deliver polished, well-briefed candidate presentations to senior stakeholders.
- Lead complex offer negotiations and manage executive onboarding transitions in partnership with People Operations.
Executive Bench & Network Management
- Manage the executive talent bench as a strategic organizational asset. Maintain active relationships with senior leaders across key functions, tracking movement, motivation, and availability. When a VP+ req opens, you will have candidates in queue ready to be considered.
- Activate and expand your network deliberately — referral sources, former colleagues, search firm contacts, industry events, and NYC’s sports and media community. Use LinkedIn Talent Insights and AI tools to generate market maps and competitive intelligence that sharpen search strategy and surface names your network hasn’t surfaced yet.
- Share executive talent signals and bench updates with TA and business leadership on a regular cadence — proactively, rather than only when a position becomes available. Surface names worth knowing, flag who’s on the move, and make the bench visible so leadership can engage it.
What We're Looking For
- 10+ years of talent acquisition experience with a majority focused on executive and VP+ recruiting — and a track record that shows relationship management and opportunistically identifying talent.
- Track record of managing executive search firm relationships — you know how to get the most out of a retained search partner and how to make the relationship a successful partnership for all.
- Deep LinkedIn Recruiter and LinkedIn Talent Insights expertise — you can run an executive talent market map from scratch and build a slate with conviction.
- Strong executive presence and communication — you're comfortable in the room with C-suite stakeholders and can represent the TA function credibly at the highest levels.
- An established executive network built on credibility, trust, and long-term professional relationships. You develop executive relationships over time and leverage those connections to support future hiring needs.
- Experience with AI recruiting tools and genuine curiosity about how to deploy them in executive search.
- Must have high EQ and discretion and have a genuine track record of adaptability and flexibility.
- Based in New York City with deep market fluency and an existing network across NYC’s sports, media, consumer, or technology ecosystem.
Tools & Tech
LinkedIn Recruiter · LinkedIn Talent Insights · Greenhouse · AI Tools (Claude, ChatGPT, Glean or equivalent) · Executive Search Firm Management · Slack · Airtable · Charthop
Why Fanatics Collectibles
Fanatics Collectibles sits at the intersection of culture, technology, and fandom — and the leaders we bring in from your network will define the next chapter. This role is based in New York City, where the talent market is dense, the relationships run deep, and the opportunity for meaningful executive engagement is significant. You’ll operate with the trust and visibility of a true senior partner: direct access to the C-suite, ownership of the executive bench, and a mandate to build something that outlasts any single search. This role offers the opportunity to make a significant impact on the future leadership of the organization.
Ensure your Fanatics job offer is legitimate and don’t fall victim to fraud. Fanatics never seeks payment from job applicants. Feel free to ask your recruiter for a phone call or other type of communication for interview, and ensure your communication is coming from a Fanatics email address (including @collectfanatics.com). For added security, where possible, apply through our company website at
The salary range represents base pay only and does not include short-term or long-term incentive compensation. This salary range is specific to New York City and may not be applicable to other locations. When determining base pay, as part of a final compensation package, we consider several factors such as location, experience, qualifications, and training. For information about our benefits, please visit
By submitting your application, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our Candidate Privacy Policy.
Fanatics will never ask candidates for money, banking information, or other sensitive personal information as part of the interview process. If you receive a suspicious message claiming to be from Fanatics recruiting, please do not respond and report it here.